Specialty Cookies 🍪

Big, beautiful cookies in artisan flavors — guaranteed to delight any cookie lover!

Cookie Monster Cookies

A whimsical treat! A chocolate chip cookie base packed with white, milk, and semi-sweet chocolate chips, crushed Oreos™, and Chips Ahoy™ cookies — all dyed the perfect shade of Cookie Monster blue.

4-pack – $14 | Add-ons – $3.50 each

Reese’s™ Peanut Butter Overload

For true peanut butter fanatics. A jumbo peanut butter cookie loaded with peanut butter chips, chocolate chips, stuffed with a full-size Reese’s™ Cup, and topped with Reese’s™ Pieces.

4-pack – $16 | Add-ons – $4 each

Cookies ’n Cream

Soft, dreamy, and sweet! Made with chopped Oreos™, creamy white chocolate chips, and chunks of Hershey’s™ Cookies ’n Creme bars.

4-pack – $12 | Add-ons – $3 each

Brownie Cookies

Decadent, rich, and extra chocolatey. This oversized cookie is made with melted chocolate, cocoa, and studded with chocolate chips — a chocoholic’s dream!

4-pack – $14 | Add-ons – $3.50 each

S’mores Cookies

All the cozy campfire vibes, without the mess. A classic s’more reimagined as a cookie — gooey, chocolatey, and oh-so nostalgic.

4-pack – $14 | Add-ons – $3.50 each

Brown Butter Toffee Pretzel

Sweet and salty perfection with nutty brown butter, pretzels, toffee pieces and chocolate chips.

4-pack – $12 | Add-ons – $3 each

The Small Batch Sampler

Build your own variety box (4-cookie minimum). Perfect for trying something new or creating a custom assortment of your favorites.

👉 See the Weekly Offerings page for this week’s flavors. Need a big batch? Reach out to inquire about special orders!

The Small Batch Baker